Once Upon a Time in Hollywood or The Irishman

Irishperson

For me it boils down to Scorsese or Tarantino and I'm anticipating Marty's quite handily

Neither. Genuinely not a fan of either of these two's work.

Probably Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, but I'm honestly not that excited for either of them yet. If ever you had two directors whose films people get way to over excited about, these are probably the two.

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

The one directed by King Scorsese .

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

At this point, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. I was hesitant about that even being a thing at first because Tarantino did not strike me as the type of director who would handle that particular subject matter intelligently or maturely. Now that more info has come out on what the movie will be like I've become gradually more and more interested. Also, it helps that Manson died. It's about time that happened. He just strikes me as the type of lunatic who would really get off on this sort of thing.

The Irishman feels like it should've been made fifteen years ago. I'm not saying it won't be good, especially because we're talking about Scorsese here (and his last movie was a knockout), but I'm definitely a little reserved in my excitement. Not to mention though that Scorsese is usually at his best when he's not making gangster films - Goodfellas the exception.

I have very little actual interest in the Tarantino project, as I feel like the material needs someone with a bit more of a level-headed maturity to treat it with the respect and dignity it deserves, which Tarantino has scarcely evinced. But with that said, I'm much more interested in that than I am in the Scorsese film, which I really don't give a shit about.

Well just as a Pacino fan and on thematic material, I know his role is significant in The Irishman and the character of Jimmy Hoffa, is one of the great characters in 20th century America and it has never been done right. That just is a different thing .....I mean there's more meat on that story.

On paper the Scorsese film actually affected how say my father lived, what he earned, where he lived, how my life went too - I mean thousands and thousands of Americans lives were affected by that story - you would be hard pressed to find another story like it, in ways you don't even see (i.e. the intersection of your day to day life, with organized crime, with the rise and fall of unions, etc.)

I prefer Scorsese generally, but Once Upon a Time in Hollywood sounds more interesting to me rn. Very hyped for both.

OUATIH, since the 60's and Manson are fascinating topics and the cast never ceases to impress me. I'm also hyped about The Irishman, but the deaging CGI stuff worries me. I wish Scorsese would've just play it safe and cast younger actors in the younger roles, as the digital deaging technology so far usually seems a bit unconvincing.