Rank this year's acting nominees

Actor
Chalamet
Oldman
Kaluuya

Actress
Hawkins
McDormand
Robbie
Ronan

Supporting Actor
Dafoe
Rockwell
Jenkins
Harrelson

Supporting Actress
Janney
Metcalf
Spencer

Right now...

Actor
1) Chalamet
2) Day-Lewis
3) Kaluuya
4) Oldman

Actress
1) Ronan
2) McDormand
3) Robbie
4) Hawkins 
5) Streep

Supporting Actor
1) Dafoe
2) Harrelson
3) Rockwell
4) Jenkins

Supporting Actress
1) Metcalf
2) Manville
3) Spencer
4) Janney
5) Blige

All together:

1) Chalamet


2) Ronan
3) Metcalf
4) Day-Lewis
5) Dafoe
6) Manville
7) McDormand


8) Kaluuya
9) Robbie
10) Hawkins
11) Streep
12) Spencer


13) Harrelson
14) Rockwell
15) Janney
16) Jenkins


17) Oldman
18) Blige

From what I've seen

Actor
Kaluuya
Oldman
Chalamet

Actress
Ronan
McDormand
Hawkins

Supporting Actor
Harrelson
Rockwell
Jenkins

Supporting Actress
Metcalf
Spencer
Blige

Tier 1
1. Oldman - Maybe not first tier Oldman performance like his 90s stuff, but I'm surprised at this stage he's still able to lead my nominations. You can argue he's all voice, and Oscar-baity, but I don't really care. I don't think that detracts from the level of talent he still has.

2. Rockwell - Takes over from the middle of the movie on.

3. Ronan - Love the accent, love the routine. Girl is definitely a talent and I don't know much of her work. Kicks Ellen Page's ass.

4. Harrelson - The male Holly Hunter, he still has the slyness and his act doesn't get old.

5. McDormand - Sans the regional accent, not sure how this is very different from her Fargo work. Maybe a little bit over infatuated, but it's still first-tier among the nominations and there's not THAT much separating #1-5 actually. Nobody way ahead or anything.


Tier 2:
6. Hawkins - So fucking naked. And while I really love her skin, I'm actually a bit underwhelmed with her performance. It's time for her to do an Oscar playing British period drama like Margaret Schlegel in Howard's End or something. And she should be first in line for those roles. I'd take her over Ronan for that.

7. Robbie - She was fun, but they could've got someone better for Harding's persona she completely missed the mark on. She didn't have to try as hard in The Wolf of Wall Street.


Tier 3:
8. Dafoe - I can name 5 Dafoe performances that are better. He still adds strength to a pretty decent Supporting Actor lineup that's been bland since forever, but I don't feel the soul everyone else feels for him, and for the film.

9. Blige - ...getting a little too much hate. Still far from nomination worthy, but is at least decent, race argument or not.


Tier 4:
10. Metcalf - Who?

11. Jenkins - unable to see this guy past an average professor dude or something.

12. Janney - kind of throwaway, dull

13. Spencer - feels like a face that's just there, and have been here lately and I'm not exactly sure why.