Rank/rate these modern queer romances/coming-of-age films.

1) Carol - 10/10
2) Moonlight - 10/10
3) Call Me by Your Name - 9/10
4) Brokeback Mountain - 8.5/10
5) Weekend - 7.5/10

N/S Blue is the Warmest Colour just yet. I really should.

Brokeback Mountain - 9/10
Call Me By Your Name - 9/10
Moonlight - 8.5/10
Weekend - 8/10
Carol - 8/10
Blue is the Warmest Color - 7.5

Brokeback Mountain: A
Weekend: A-/B+
Blue is the Warmest Color: B+
Carol: A+
Moonlight: A-/B+
Call Me By Your Name: A

Ranking them...

1. Carol
2. Brokeback Mountain
3. Call Me By Your Name
4. Moonlight
5. Weekend
6. Blue is the Warmest Color

I love all of them - each makes my Top 10 of its respective release year.

1. Moonlight
2. Carol
3. Brokeback Mountain
4. Blue is the Warmest Color

Haven't yet seen Call Me By Your Name, and I haven't even heard of Weekend. 

Oh ok, the school of the lame and mediocre, i'll rank them accordingly.

1. Brokeback Mountain - 7.5  Used to think more highly of it.  But it didn't age well for me.  The story felt like sentiment at the time, and society has kind of subtlely evolved since 2005 to where that type of sentimentality over some sad guitar is no longer as effective.  But that being said, it's still a solid, well told story.  It starts better but runs a little out of story once Ennis starts to meander around town alone lamenting over Jack.  I think Ang Lee has overall better films, but I'm still glad this exists, for discussion and point-in-time references.  Not that I consider every film here lame or mediocre.

2. Blue is the Warmest - 7.5 I think it's good, but it's fairly conventionally told and it didn't end up doing anything to shift cinema.  Adele definitely shines, I don't know if she's a one-hit wonder, but speaking just of this film she was definitely a sight to behold.  I usually don't connect well with those tales of adolescences, unless it's American Honey with its journey into the heart of Americana.  It's so interesting this has become your girlfriend's favorite movie (or one of), and I don't see it as having enough emotional power for an average viewer, but maybe there's something I'm missing.

3. Moonlight - 6 Recently rewatched.  Story was pretty average, but it can lay credit to sometimes capturing Weerasethakul, but I still like him more, I think his stories are generally more substantial and his movies capture more great moments.  Moonlight felt lacking in that, and that whole storyline with the caricature bully guy, and then in the diner when they were mellowing out were just lacking for me.

4. Carol  - 4.5 post-Far From Heaven Haynes is really disappointing.  He kinda sucks sometimes, this is one of the best examples.  So artificial feeling.  So manipulated and not allowed to naturally unfold as a story.  

Blue is the Warmest Color 10. It's vibrant and alive, feels like a statement, Adele might be one of my favourite characters of the century, I could've watch 3 more hours of her life and I wouldn't complain. Even the cinematography does somehing to not be didactic. 

Brokeback Mountain 10. I felt in love with it 12 years ago, rewatched it recently and I still amazed by how Lee manage to get away with such a tragic story without portraying the characters as martyrs, especially for the period the movie is told, again for me every single element of the film makes it visceral, you can almost feel it, and marvelous performances all around. 

Call Me By Your Name 9, Yeah, I've said much about this one

Carol 8. Same, just reaffirming that I admire how straight forward it is but within the lines feels as part of something bigger and modern, and technical aspects and direction elevates it, but at times feels wrapped in cellophane. 

Weekend 7 maybe 8. The strength comes from the frank sense of humor, is very sincere and uncomfortable, that creates the individuality of the characters, I've seen a few other movies try this but are caught in stereotypes. Nice cinematography btw

Moonlight 4. king of hackers

Yeah, what a burden for you. 

Carol
Brokeback Mountain
Moonlight
Call Me By Your Name
Blue is the Warmest Color
Weekend