Oscar upset: Timothée Chalamet & Saoirse Ronan both win

I would love to see Ronan win.

I would be fine with Chalamet winning but I didn't think his performance was OMG Best Eva! Like the raves are suggesting. And if I'm being honest the idea of Gary Oldman being an Oscar winner is more appealing for me.

Hahahaha!! I feel the same way about Ronan.

Christ_Ian_Bale - If it's any consolation... He turned 22 today. 

I've not seen Chalamet's competition, but I wasn't all that blown away by his performance. He was good, but I genuinely don't see why everyone is losing their collective minds over his performance. I think one of the things that irritates me most about the film is how everything feels portrayed at arm's length, and that level of detachment kind of kills any investment I have in his character, and even though I think that final shot is haunting, I don't rest its power entirely on Chalamet's shoulders. The music goes a hell of a long way towards making that shot work as well as it does. I know people would call it sacrilegious to say anything about Chalamet that isn't vaunting praise, but if he were to win, I'd rate him above Redmayne and Affleck but below the other Best Actor winners this decade. Still, it'd be pretty neat to see the Academy go for someone young in that category for once, and I'd hope to see Chalamet avoid the Timothy Hutton trap if he does.

Similarly, Ronan's performance frustrates me as much as Chalamet's, and for largely the same reason. I didn't find Lady Bird or Elio to be likable characters, and while I feel that both actors are innately charming, I found them largely unsympathetic. In Ronan's case, I think her accent work and buoyancy is admirable, but the film was just 2Gerwig4Me, and it all came together to create a character that was technically impressive but otherwise aggravating as hell. Unlike Chalamet, I have seen at least one performance Ronan is up against, and as much as I love Saoirse in general, if she beats McDormand, it's highway robbery of the highest order.

they give my two favorite performances of the year in their perspective categories, so I'd be fine with it. Would Ronan really be an upset though?

Haven’t seen much this year but Chalamet is remarkable and Ronan is good, so just on that basis I wouldn’t be disappointed. Having said that, I doubt that the latter is the best in her category. Lady Bird hits all the right notes but it’s ultimately a pretty slight film and Ronan’s performance doesn’t confer much weight to it, either. She was still better than last year’s winner, though (not that that would take very much).

Chalamet is by far and away my favourite performance of the year from what I've seen, and I'd love if he won. I've yet to see Oldman, Day-Lewis and a few others, but I'd be shocked if I liked them more than Chalamet. 

Having just watched Lady Bird and Three Billboards, I'm torn over whether I prefer Ronan or McDormand. Right now I'm leaning slightly towards the former, but either one winning would be fantastic.

Trully happy because I'm tired that old guys are the
only winning ones.

The younges academy award winner was 29 Adam Brody who looks much older, maybe that's why he won.

Any way my prediction is Gary Oldman and booby Robbie.-

I would be fine with both of those. I wouldn't consider either an upset though, since best actress can go to anyone and Chamalet has currently been a winning a lot of the awards lately.

I'd be fucking ecstatic. My two favorite performances of the year so far.