|
Post by DeepArcher on Dec 22, 2021 14:23:16 GMT
Anyone else checked this out yet?
New HBO series based on the novel by Emily St. John Mandel (I coincidentally just finished reading the novel before the series released, didn't even plan it that way!), created by former Leftovers writer Patrick Somerville, ensemble cast including Mackenzie Davis, Himesh Patel, and Gael García Bernal.
First three episodes are out now on HBO Max and are very, very good. It manages to take on the subject matter of an apocalyptic pandemic in a way that is both stressful and comforting, without going out of its way to resonate with real-life circumstances (the novel was written years before COVID and the show even started production before the pandemic; real-life parallels entirely, weirdly coincidental). The entire vibe of the show is definitely Leftovers reminiscent in a way that I really love -- perfect blending of different tones, there's a real sorrow to it but not without a sense of dark humor, with a novelistic, ambitious approach to its storytelling and real sensitivity towards each of its characters. The performances have been great across the board, but the MVPs are so far are Matilda Lawler (genuinely one of the best child performances I've seen in ... years?) and Danielle Deadwyler (her ep. 3 performance is one for the record books).
Looking forward to the rest of this in the coming weeks. Would definitely recommend checking out!
|
|
|
Post by DeepArcher on Dec 27, 2021 5:23:10 GMT
Hmmm maybe a false alarm here. Eps. 4 & 5 were both pretty bad ... ep. 4 especially which is like bafflingly out of place tonally with the first three episodes ... truly wtf casting of David Cross, stupid shit with landmines ... just not good. Ep. 5 is a bit better (David Wilmot is a really charming Clark) but kinda totally fumbles with some of the strongest material in the book ... and features one of the most unintentionally hilarious things I've seen in awhile when the kid who grows up to be a dangerous cult leader is looking at the last thing he downloaded from the Internet before the Internet ceased to exist and it's the Wikipedia page for Capitalism ... this is a moment that the show seems to think is subtle and plays without a hint of irony, to be clear ... in fact basically everything with the Tyler character is unintentionally hilarious and again really ruinous to the tone that this had set in those first three episodes (eps. 1 & 3 especially). I'll try to stick with it because I do like the book ... maybe foreground Lawler, Patel, Deadwyler, Bernal again and I'll be back into it.
|
|
|
Post by Martin Stett on Jun 20, 2022 1:25:40 GMT
Episode 1 was one of the most laughably moronic things I have seen in recent memory. I would love to see a good apocalypse story, but this fucked up jumble of motivations and ridiculously over-the-top and overdramatic portrayal of the disaster itself immediately turned me off. Subtlety can go a long, long way, writers. (For example, the Finnish and Swedish sections of the prologue to Stand Still Stay Silent demonstrate a lot of restraint in showing people who know that the sickness is unstoppable and universally fatal without resorting to DRAMATIC plane crashes or DRAMATIC hospitals or DRAMATIC escapes or DRAMATIC panic attacks. Sundberg allows the dread to envelop the characters instead of forcing dramatic situations onto them. And Sundberg is writing a rather comical story with silly banter and exaggerated, eccentric personalities!) There wasn't one convincing thing about the way people acted or the way the situation developed. (That shot of the security guard at the end had me in absolute stitches! ...But it was meant to be serious. ) There is no development of Jeevan to explain why he would suddenly take this girl in, no development as to why she can't fucking call her parents, no sense to the way his sister suddenly goes RUN AWAY NOW out of fucking nowhere (presumably she'd have been doing that shit for ages before this, why would she suddenly freak out now? ) and absolutely nothing here that I think is the slightest bit rational. So yeah, one episode is enough for me to scratch this one off.
|
|