|
|
Post by urbanpatrician on Jul 3, 2020 6:40:41 GMT
pacinoyes yo rundown? '73: Lead Actor - Serpico (No idea who wins, I guess one of the Robert Redford performances. I hate the year) '74: Lead Actor - The Godfather: Part 2 ( WIN) '75: Lead Actor - Dog Day Afternoon (between Nicholson and Pacino, I prefer Nicholson. No idea who wins overall) '83: Lead Actor - Scarface ( WIN) '90: Lead Actor - The Local Stigmatic (Not sure who wins.... Depardieu, Byrne, Penn, Cage, Nolte.... it's a bad year ) '90: Supporting Actor - Dick Tracy ( WIN) '92: Supporting Actor - Glengarry Glen Ross (#3 behind Studi and Davison) '97: Lead Actor - Donnie Brasco ( WIN) '99: Lead Actor - The Insider (#2 behind Crowe) '04: Lead Actor - The Merchant of Venice (#5 behind Washington, Giamatti, Cruise, and Hanks) He's on my radar for 4 or 5 other movies. I haven't seen The Irishman, but it's on my library queue. Needs some more months.
|
|
|
|
Post by pacinoyes on Jul 3, 2020 8:45:15 GMT
I'm a little burned out on Pacino tbh, blah blah blah I'm sure if you look up my past history you can find my thoughts and the Pacino stans will be here ......nah j/k I'm not a dick ........and I can take 2 minutes and be polite can't I? Yeah I can  ********************************************************************************************** He's actually an awards "problem" because some of his best work just can't be nodded - particularly Scarecrow because he can only get 1 per category in 1973, and Local Stigmatic (love it, in my top 5 for him, but too short (50 mins) and never released in theaters anyway) .......and of course TV since that is um.......TV. That takes out 4 of my top 10 Pacino performances!  Panic in Needle Park, The Godfather (BSA or BA win whichever), Serpico, The Godfather Part II (win), Dog Day Afternoon (win), And Justice For All, Dick Tracy (support), Scarface, Glengarry Glen Ross (support), Scent of A Woman, Heat, Donnie Brasco, The Irishman (support). So somewhere around ~13 Oscar nods, 3 wins .......bunch of top 10s .....  |
|
|
|
Post by TerryMontana on Jul 3, 2020 9:04:29 GMT
GF I (BA, not BSA)
Serpico
GF II - WIN
DDA - Him or Jack for the win
And Justice for All
Scarface (him or Duvall, Finney, Caine ftw)
GF III
Scent of a Woman
Donnie Brasco (BSA)
The Insider (BSA)
Merchant of Venice (BA or BSA, whatever)
The Irishman (BSA)
That's about 2 Oscars in a total of 12 nods. Unfortunately for him, his tv work and Chinese Coffee were ineligible. As a matter of fact, I just decided to rewatch Chinese Coffee...
|
|
|
|
Post by urbanpatrician on Jul 3, 2020 9:13:48 GMT
I'm a little burned out on Pacino tbh, blah blah blah I'm sure if you look up my past history you can find my thoughts and the Pacino stans will be here ......nah j/k I'm not a dick ........and I can take 2 minutes and be polite can't I? Yeah I can Lol. Agreed.... that was huh wtf  to me as well. Still no idea where your feud started. Guessing Angels in America and Chinese Coffee are the other 2? I don't really care about eligibility whatever personally... I guess he would be a 9 time nominee for me instead of 10 in that case. |
|
|
|
Post by pupdurcs on Jul 3, 2020 9:19:02 GMT
I'm a little burned out on Pacino tbh, blah blah blah I'm sure if you look up my past history you can find my thoughts and the Pacino stans will be here ......nah j/k I'm not a dick ........and I can take 2 minutes and be polite can't I? Yeah I can Lol. Agreed.... that was huh wtf to me as well. I said it with a smile, didn't I  . It was clearly time to give that topic a rest for awhile (especially in terms of fresh threads), and judging by the amount of people who liked that post where I said what I said, I echoed the sentiment of many. Nothing personal, but it's about reading the room. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 3, 2020 9:22:27 GMT
Don't have lineups assembled but I'd guess if I put them together he definitely gets wins for The Godfather Part II and Angels in America (I don't separate miniseries/limited series from films when counting my favorites, don't see any reason to), maybe Scarface and Sea of Love too. Bunch of nominations
|
|
|
|
Post by JangoB on Jul 3, 2020 9:35:42 GMT
1971: Best Actor, The Panic in Needle Park (#5)
1972: Best Actor, The Godfather (#2)
1973: Best Actor, Serpico
1973: Best Actor, Scarecrow (#3)
1974: Best Actor, The Godfather: Part II
1975: Best Actor, Dog Day Afternoon
1979: Best Actor, And Justice for All (#5)
1983: Best Actor, Scarface (#2)
1990: Best Supporting Actor, Dick Tracy (#2)
1992: Best Actor, Scent of a Woman (#3)
1992: Best Supporting Actor, Glengarry Glen Ross (#4)
1997: Best Actor, Donnie Brasco (#2)
2019: Best Supporting Actor, The Irishman (#2)
3 wins + 10 nominations
|
|
|
|
Post by jimmalone on Jul 3, 2020 9:38:41 GMT
Out of my head:
1972, Best Leading Actor: The Godfather
1973, Best Leading Actor: Serpico
1974, Best Leading Actor: The Godfather II***
1975, Best Leading Actor: Dog Day Afternoon***
1979, Best Leading Actor: And Justice for All
1983, Best Leading Actor: Scarface
1992, Best Leading Actor: Scent of a Woman***
1992, Best Supporting Actor: Glengarry Glen Ross
1995, Best Leading Actor: Heat***
1997, Best Supporting Actor: Donnie Brasco
2002, Best Leading Actor: Insomnia
2019, Best Supporting Actor: The Irishman***
So that would be 12 nods with 5 wins among them.
|
|
|
|
Post by pacinoyes on Jul 3, 2020 9:43:43 GMT
Guessing Angels in America and Chinese Coffee are the other 2? I don't really care about eligibility whatever personally... I guess he would be a 9 time nominee for me instead of 10 in that case. Chinese Coffee would actually be more eligible for an "Oscar list" the way I think of it than Local Stigmatic is in a way since it at least has the length of a feature film - see THAT'S how much of a weird PITA he is ........ his two "TV top 10s" to me are AiA and YDK Jack (2010) - his 2 Emmy wins. A great statistic for his genius/bullsh it is this: there are just 4 male actors who got an Oscar nomination, Tony nomination and Emmy nomination (and a win!) in the 2010s - Pacino, Mark Rylance, Bryan Cranston, Adam Driver .......and he's significantly older than the other 3. People don't think of "Al Pacino is the Best Actor of the 2010s!....." and he's not actually ........ but he also never goes away either.....he's sort of always there haunting us ............like the IRS.......or Covid.....  |
|
|
|
Post by TerryMontana on Jul 3, 2020 10:08:09 GMT
Wow!! I'd give the man only(!) two Oscars and some of you would give him 4 or 5!!! And I thought I was a die hard fan!!
PS. If AiA and YDKJ were eligible for the Oscars, him getting nominated would be a no-brainer. Possibly with two wins, also.
|
|
|
|
Post by mikediastavrone96 on Jul 3, 2020 15:24:44 GMT
1971: Best Actor - The Panic in Needle Park
1972: Best Actor - The Godfather***
1973: Best Actor - Serpico
1974: Best Actor - The Godfather: Part II***
1975: Best Actor - Dog Day Afternoon***
1979: Best Actor - ...And Justice for All
1983: Best Actor - Scarface***
1990: Best Supporting Actor - Dick Tracy
1992: Best Supporting Actor - Glengarry Glen Ross
2019: Best Supporting Actor - The Irishman
10 noms/4 wins
|
|
|
|
Post by Mattsby on Jul 3, 2020 16:25:03 GMT
1971 - Lead Actor, Panic in Needle Park1972 - Lead Actor, The Godfather1973 - Lead Actor, Scarecrow1973 - Lead Actor, Serpico1974 - Lead Actor, The Godfather: Part II 1975 - Lead Actor, Dog Day Afternoon1980 - Lead Actor, Cruising 1983 - Lead Actor, Scarface1990 - Lead Actor, Local Stigmatic1992 - Lead Actor, Scent of a Woman1992 - Supporting Actor, Glengarry Glen Ross1995 - Lead Actor, Heat1997 - Lead Actor, Donnie Brasco2000 - Lead Actor, Chinese Coffee 2004 - Supporting Actor, Merchant of Venice2015 - Lead Actor, The Humbling/Manglehorn/Danny Collins2019 - Supporting Actor, The Irishman and if we counted the HBOs... 2003 - Lead Actor, AiA 2010 - Lead Actor, YDKJ 2013 - Lead Actor, Phil Spector 2018 - Lead Actor, Paterno   |
|
|
|
Post by dadsburgers on Jul 3, 2020 16:38:26 GMT
1972 Lead, The Godfather (loses to Marlon Brando in the same)
1973 Lead, Serpico
1974 Lead, The Godfather Part II
1975 Lead, Dog Day Afternoon
1979 Lead, And Justice for All (loses to Dustin Hoffman in Kramer vs. Kramer)
1983 Lead, Scarface (loses to Robert DeNiro in King of Comedy)
1990 Supporting, Dick Tracy (loses to Joe Pesci in Goodfellas)
1992 Lead, Glengarry Glen Ross (loses to Tim Roth in Reservoir Dogs)
2019 Supporting, The Irishman (loses to Willem Dafoe in The Lighthouse)
|
|
|
|
Post by Tommen_Saperstein on Jul 3, 2020 22:27:05 GMT
re: the conversation surrounding Pacino/De Niro/Hoffman/Nicholson i did a quick count of my own lineups and found out that I nominate Pacino the most with seven, followed by Nicholson with six, Hoffman with five and De Niro only with three. So that's my contribution to the discussion.
Pacino is wonderful. Remember not long ago that I said I preferred Hoffman. I think I still do, I don't know. Maybe The Irishman pushes him ahead because that perf is among his best work (that's right, his best) and Hoffman has been irrelevant for years now. What I do know is that no one had a better run in the 70s than Pacino. At the very least he'll always have that. It's when he lets himself go that I tend to lose interest. Still haven't seen Scent of a Woman but I'm not expecting to like it...
anyways
1972: Best Actor, The Godfather
1973: Best Actor, Serpico
1974: Best Actor, The Godfather Part II
1975: Best Actor, Dog Day Afternoon (runner-up to Tim Curry)
1992: Best Supporting Actor, Glengary Glen Ross
1999: Best Actor, The Insider
2019: Best Supporting Actor, The Irishman (runner-up to Dafoe)
He comes close for Panic in Needle Park but doesn't quite cut the top 5, and like I always say, I have more to see, including some big ones like Donnie Brasco.
|
|
futuretrunks
Based
Posts: 3,245
Likes: 1,436
Member is Online
|
Post by futuretrunks on Jul 3, 2020 23:33:08 GMT
The Godfather
The Godfather Part II
Scarface
Scent of a Woman
Donnie Brasco
3 wins, 5+ nominations
There's probably a few more, but they'd be for films I haven't finished. I also don't remember how much I liked him in The Insider. Haven't seen Glengarry Glen Ross or Scarecrow or Panic in Needle Park. Only saw about 60% of Dog Day Afternoon and when I went back to finish it, it was no longer on demand at the time.
|
|
|
|
Post by therealcomicman117 on Jul 4, 2020 22:46:29 GMT
1972: Best Actor - The Godfather
1973: Best Actor - Serpico
1974: Best Actor - The Godfather Part II
1975: Best Actor - Dog Day Afternoon (runner-up to Tim Curry)
1983: Best Actor - Scarface
1990: Best Supporting Actor - Dick Tracy
1992: Best Supporting Actor - Glengarry Glen Ross
1999: Best Actor - The Insider
2019: Best Supporting Actor - The Irishman
9 Noms / 1 Win
|
|
to me as well. Still no idea where your feud started.
. It was clearly time to give that topic a rest for awhile (especially in terms of fresh threads), and judging by the amount of people who liked that post where I said what I said, I echoed the sentiment of many. Nothing personal, but it's about reading the room.
