'Gone with the Wind' or 'Titanic' ?

I adore them both but I adore "Gone with the Wind" much more!

Is there an alternative ending of Gone With the Wind where Rhett Butler yells "THAT REALLY SUCKS, LADY!" into Scarlett's face?

I'd say the one that is the greatest mounted production in Hollywood history - certainly before 1950 at least - that has some great acting in it (which Titanic really doesn't as much tbh). I mean Titanic is better when people aren't even talking at all - and also and not coincidentally the one that still upsets people and got this pathetic/laughable tag applied to it as recently as just THIS week below in bold - I mean would anyone give af about Titanic enough to attempt to place it into full context so our wackjob 2020 outrage could attempt to be pacified with a "statement before the film?"?

I mean GWTW is a whole different beast in a lot of ways ........historically, culturally, emotionally....


“The film’s treatment of this world through a lens of nostalgia denies the horrors of slavery, as well as its legacies of racial inequality.”

Reminds me A LOT of my 11th wife who cruelly told me she had fake every orgasm during our marriage and how she was a "better actress than the lady from Titanic" - the multiple levels of cruelty were almost too much for a man of my age to bear.

This, it's incredible how cheesy Titanic is at times. The production values really save that movie, imho.

I think Winslet does her best with the material she was given but yeah, Leo was horrendous. He's really improved over the years. 

One is an iconic classic that has stood the test of time for 80 years while the other is a giant sack of shit. This poll is an insult to the former.

If you had been around in 39 you'd have given Vivien Leigh some serious competition for playing Scarlett, MsMovieStar

Quite hard for me to take either seriously - which this board tends to do, laughably. Both come from the school of the sap-o-dramas leaning heavily the demographic of women. You can't call one a cheesy soap opera and say with a straight face that the other one isn't. Sorry. That's just no can do.

That being said, Titanic is more entertaining with the abandon ship scenes, the Jack/Rose stuff with some childlike courtships - whenever they're not forcing corny romantic lines on each other, and there were some moments where it came off Terence Davies like (which is good). I would rank it #2 out of the 90s Best Picture winners which isn't saying much because most of those aren't good at all.

Gone With the Wind has Gable on a horse thru scorching fire which reached a peak for me personally, but that's not saying much because it's a small peak when the film was mediocre to begin with. However, Gone With the Wind has the FAR better acting, and don't really see any arguments to make there. Gable destroys DiCaprio. De Havilland was better than any supporting female in Titanic even tho Frances Fisher might've been the only one really snubbed. Leigh is better than Winslet - one is good the other is just mediocre and took a spot from Kudrow or Sorvino.