Rank/Rate the Best Picture Winners - 1 big ass list

2020 - "Parasite" - NS
2019 - "Green Book" - NS
2018 - "The Shape of Water" - 6 
2017 - "Moonlight" - 7
2016 - "Spotlight" - NS
2015 - "Birdman" - NS
2014 - "12 Years a Slave" - NS
2013 - "Argo" - NS
2012 - "The Artist" - NS
2011 - "The King's Speech" - 6
2010 - "The Hurt Locker" - 7
2009 - "Slumdog Millionaire" - 7 (Would be better if we had a better lead than Freida Pinto.  A girl with more longing and deep eyes would elevate this to at least a film with a memorable lead in the Bollywood style)
2008 - "No Country for Old Men" - 8
2007 - "The Departed" - 6
2006 - "Crash" - 6
2005 - "Million Dollar Baby" - 5
2004 - "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" - 9
2003 - "Chicago" - 7
2002 - "A Beautiful Mind" - 7.5
2001 - "Gladiator" - 7
2000 - "American Beauty" - 7.5
1999 - "Shakespeare in Love" - 5 (worst than I thought upon a rewatch.  Such fluff.)
1998 - "Titanic" - 8
1997 - "The English Patient" - 7
1996 - "Braveheart" - 6
1995 - "Forrest Gump" - 8
1994 - "Schindler’s List" - 7.5
1993 - "Unforgiven" - 9
1992 - "The Silence of the Lambs" - 6
1991 - "Dances With Wolves" - 6
1990 - "Driving Miss Daisy" - 6
1989 - "Rain Man" - 6
1988 - "The Last Emperor" - 7.5
1987 - "Platoon" - 8
1986 - "Out of Africa" - 6
1985 - "Amadeus" - 9
1984 - "Terms of Endearment" - 7.5
1983 - "Gandhi" - 6
1982 - "Chariots of Fire" - (6, maybe a rewatch needed)
1981 - "Ordinary People" - 7
1980 - "Kramer vs. Kramer" - 7
1979 - "The Deer Hunter" - 7 
1978 - "Annie Hall" - 9
1977 - "Rocky" - 7
1976 - "One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest" - 7.5 (maybe 7.75, I dunno.  But couldn't pull that 8 from me just quite)
1975 - "The Godfather Part II" - 9.5
1974 - "The Sting" - 6
1973 - "The Godfather" - 9.5
1972 - "The French Connection" - 7
1971 - "Patton" - 7
1970 - "Midnight Cowboy" - 7.5
1969 - "Oliver!" - (don't remember.  6 by default)
1968 - "In the Heat of the Night" - 7.5
1967 - "A Man for All Seasons" - 5
1966 - "The Sound of Music" - 6
1965 - "My Fair Lady" - 5
1964 - "Tom Jones" - (again.... by default.... 6)
1963 - "Lawrence of Arabia" - 9
1962 - "West Side Story" - 6
1961 - "The Apartment" - 7
1960 - "Ben-Hur" - 8
1959 - "Gigi" - (6.... don't remember)
1958 - "The Bridge on the River Kwai" - 9
1957 - "Around the World in 80 Days" - 8 (I'm the only one, but I really dug it)
1956 - "Marty" - 7.5 (interesting film that won.... but ultimately just feels cute and lighthearted)
1955 - "On the Waterfront" - 7 (story is weak.... but I'll give it a 7 because it's a relatively nicely produced film.  Still feels kinda weaksauce tho.)
1954 - "From Here to Eternity" - 8
1953 - "The Greatest Show on Earth" - 5
1952 - "An American in Paris" - 7
1951 - "All About Eve" - 7.5
1950 - "All the Kings Men" - 6
1949 - "Hamlet" - 7.5
1948 - "Gentleman's Agreement" - (don't remember at all)
1947 - "The Best Years of Our Lives" - 7 (fun stories.  Maybe deserves a 7.5, but war veteran sentimentality is just blegh.  I'm not anti-right wing sentiment at all, but I dunno... I felt some stories needed more strength and others less.  I do like Teresa Wright and the growth of her womanhood though.  She's the strongest actress in the film, and she could've elevated it if her story were more substantial.  Dana Andrews was the best actor and his story while solid could've been stronger.  I don't like Hollywood making men appear like wimps with no ability to support themselves.  Too easy to gain sympathy that way, and also tack on a stereotypical under-provided throwaway girlfriend character Virginia Mayo.  Ok... i'll just give it a 7.5)
1946 - "The Lost Weekend" - 7
1945 - "Going My Way" - (no recollection at all)
1944 - "Casablanca" - 10 (perfect)
1943 - "Mrs. Miniver" - 7 (would probably be a 6 in normal cases since it's such a hogwash film, but I love wartime peril type films.  They feel fanciful)
1942 - "How Green Was My Valley" - 5 (yeah.... it puts me to sleep, sorry)
1941 - "Rebecca" - 9.5 (looks and feels like European arthouse.  Feels like a Bergman, except Hitchcock doesn't usually have those "haunted by death and sickness" like Bergman does.  But he does like to create intrigue which is less Bergman's thing.  Both are strong at creating some really engaging drama between characters that initially are perceived as young and innocent and caught up in a gothic drama that escalates from that point on)
1940 - "Gone with the Wind" - 7 (feeling generous.  A 7.  It's still kinda entertaining even if it's obvious kinda draw-attention kind of entertainment like Titanic with the set places, the romantic "my soul love" type stuff, and Clark Gable background a scorching fire on a horse playing heroine is kinda fun)
1939 - "You Can't Take It with You" - 7
1938 - "The Life of Emile Zola" - (no thoughts here)
1937 - "The Great Ziegfeld" - (nope, none)
1936 - "Mutiny on the Bounty" - 8
1935 - "It Happened One Night" - 7.5
1933/1934 - "Cavalcade" - (yeah... getting to those rarely talked about winners I didn't put much effort on) 
1932/1933 - "Grand Hotel" - 7
1931/1932 - "Cimarron" - 6
1930/1931 - "All Quiet on the Western Front" - 9

The Godfather - 10
The Godfather Part II - 10
Unforgiven - 10
Lawrence of Arabia - 10
No Country For Old Men - 10
The Apartment - 10
Amadeus - 10
Annie Hall - 10
Chariots of Fire - 10
Gone with the Wind - 10
Titanic - 10
Casablanca - 10
Gladiator - 10
Rocky - 10

The Best Years of our Lives - 9
All Quiet on the Western Front - 9
Dances with Wolves - 9
Parasite - 9
Rebecca - 9
The Artist - 9
Midnight Cowboy - 9
The Silence of the Lambs - 9
Ben-Hur - 9
The Hurt Locker - 9
Schindler's List - 9
It Happened One Night - 9
The Bridge on the River Kwai - 9
The Lost Weekend - 9

The Last Emperor - 8
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - 8
On the Waterfront - 8
The Deer Hunter - 8
You Can't Take It With You - 8
Forrest Gump - 8
Shakespeare in Love - 8
The Departed - 8
The King's Speech - 8
Oliver! - 8
The English Patient - 8
All the King's Men - 8
Moonlight - 8

From Here To Eternity - 7
Gandhi - 7
Chicago - 7
Rain Man - 7
Platoon - 7
American Beauty - 7
In the Heat of the Night - 7
My Fair Lady - 7
The Sting - 7
Mrs. Miniver - 7
Patton - 7
Ordinary People - 7
Mutiny on the Bounty - 7
Hamlet - 7
The French Connection - 7

The Greatest Show on Earth - 6
All About Eve - 6
Marty - 6
How Green Was My Valley - 6
Braveheart - 6
The Sound of Music - 6
A Man For All Seasons - 6
An American in Paris - 6
Driving Miss Daisy - 6
The Shape of Water - 6
Going My Way - 6
Million Dollar Baby - 6
Argo - 6

Green Book - 5
Tom Jones - 5
The Return of the King - 5
Spotlight - 5
West Side Story - 5
12 Years a Slave - 5
A Beautiful Mind - 5
Kramer vs. Kramer - 5
Terms of Endearment - 5
Grand Hotel - 5
The Great Ziegfeld - 5
Wings - 5
The Broadway Melody - 5

Crash - 4
Birdman - 4
Out of Africa - 4
Slumdog Millionaire - 4

Cimarron - 3
Gigi - 3

Around the World in Eighty Days - 2
Gentleman's Agreement - 2

boxd.it/1i1OM

Probably something like that, didn't put a ton time reranking.

I've seen pretty much all the available nominees as well. There are some missing ones and a few that are in special archives, and I think of the ones I haven't seen that I theoretically could, I'm only missing five or so, all from the early-to-mid '30s.

Honestly, when taken in aggregate, the actual winners are mostly pretty good. The top half of my list is pretty strong, and honestly it's around the Wings/Tom Jones tier where things start to slip. I only really dislike the bottom fifteen or so, but most of those still have some worthwhile aspects. Rarely has the Academy ever picked the straight-up worst film of the field, though, which I feel like they did with the bottom ten movies on my list.

just threw this together.

10/10
1. Lawrence of Arabia (1962)
2. The Godfather (1972)
3. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
4. The Godfather: Part II (1974)
5. Parasite (2019)
6. Gone with the Wind (1939)
7. No Country for Old Men (2007)
8. The Sound of Music (1965)
9. All About Eve (1950)

9/10
10. Midnight Cowboy (1969)
11. A Man for All Seasons (1966)
12. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
13. Tom Jones (1963)
14. Spotlight (2015)
15. Amadeus (1984)
16. Schindler's List (1993)

8/10
17. In the Heat of the Night (1967)
18. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975)
19. On the Waterfront (1954)
20. West Side Story (1961)
21. The Last Emperor (1987)
22. Ordinary People (1980)
23. Ben-Hur (1959)
24. The Best Years of Our Lives (1946)
25. The Sting (1973)
26. Moonlight (2016)
27. Driving Miss Daisy (1989)
28. Chicago (2002)
29. The Artist (2011)

7.5/10
30. Platoon (1986)
31. The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957)
32. The Hurt Locker (2009)
33. Forrest Gump (1994)
34. Patton (1970)
35. Gandhi (1982)
36. The Shape of Water (2017)
37. Annie Hall (1977)

7/10
38. The Departed (2006)
39. Birdman (2014)
40. A Beautiful Mind (2001)
41. Braveheart (1995)
42. The French Connection (1971)
43. Argo (2012)
44. Gladiator (2000)
45. Chariots of Fire (1981)
46. Shakespeare in Love (1998)
47. Marty (1955)
48. The Apartment (1960)

6/10
49. 12 Years a Slave (2013)
50. The Deer Hunter (1978)
51. Unforgiven (1992)
52. Terms of Endearment (1983)
53. From Here to Eternity (1953)
54. American Beauty (1999)
55. Rocky (1976)
56. Titanic (1997)
57. Casablanca (1943)
58. The King's Speech (2010)
59. Rain Man (1988)
60. You Can't Take It with You (1938)

5/10
61. Green Book (2018)
62. Slumdog Millionaire (2008)
63. Kramer vs. Kramer (1979)
64. Out of Africa (1985)
65. Dances with Wolves (1990)
66. My Fair Lady (1964)
67. The English Patient (1996)

4/10
68. Million Dollar Baby (2004)

69. 3/10
Crash (2005)

don't remember
Around the World in Eighty Days (1956)

NS the rest. The latest BP I'm missing is Oliver! and I'm also missing a couple from the 50s but I haven't seen hardly any from the 40s or 30s.

Joining the charade.

1. The Best Years of Our Lives
2. All About Eve
3. From Here to Eternity
4. No Country for Old Men
5. Gone with the Wind
6. Casablanca
7. Amadeus
8. The Sting
9. Shakespeare in Love (I don't care)
10. The Lord of the Rings: the Return of the King
11. Rebecca
12. The Deer Hunter
13. All Quiet on the Western Front
14. The Bridge on the River Kwai
15. The Sound of Music
16. The Apartment
17. The Godfather
18. Unforgiven
19. Lawrence of Arabia
20. The Lost Weekend
21. The Silence of the Lambs
22. The Hurt Locker
23. Marty
24. Kramer vs. Kramer
25. Gladiator
26. In the Heat of the Night
27. Everything Everywhere All at Once
28. Nomadland
29. On the Waterfront
30. It Happened One Night
31. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
32. Parasite
33. Annie Hall
34. All the King's Men
35. Mrs. Miniver
36. CODA
37. Ordinary People
38. The King's Speech
39. The Shape of Water
40. A Man for All Seasons
41. Moonlight
42. Birdman
43. Forrest Gump
44. 12 years a Slave
45. Spotlight
46. The Artist
47. Midnight Cowboy
48. A Beautiful Mind
49. Terms of Endearment
50. The English Patient
51. How Green Was My Valley
52. Rain Man
53. Argo
54. Chicago
55. Titanic
56. Schindler's List
57. Million Dollar Baby
58. The Departed
59. American Beauty
60. Crash
61. Green Book

Only 35 to go. Tbf I doubt I'd love any of the rest of them..